January 15, 2013

Do you like this?

Let’s be honest. The United Methodist Church has done a remarkably poor job living up to its stated mission ["making disciples of Jesus Christ" (1996) "for the transformation of the world" (2008)]. In the same way that the Igniting Ministry media campaign failed to live up to its slogan of "Open Hearts, Open Minds, Open Doors" (more people find closed minds, hearts and doors in the UMC than experience a radical openness), our entire denomination is failing to deliver well-equipped, highly motivated, deeply committed disciples engaged in world-transforming activity.

The misguided attempts at restructuring our church have as much to do with missional ambiguity and ignorance as with intentional resistance or political sabotage. How do you adopt an “appropriate” structure when you don’t know what results you are trying to produce? The existing structure is not designed to produce authentic discipleship, and the various recommendations and “plans” weren’t designed for discipleship either.

The sad fact is, discipleship is that to which we pay lip service, not what we desire with all our heart, mind, soul and strength.

A system is designed for the results it is getting. Those 18th and 19th century holdovers from historic United Methodism and its antecedents were designed for the pre-modern and proto-modern culture they served. Mere modifications and adjustments to centuries old conventions is foolish. (Think about what our current state of being would be if medicine and science thad adopted a similar mindset!)  We are old wine in new skins — and we are shocked when there is leakage and bursting.

The United Methodist Church in North America in 2013 is not committed to discipleship.  It is committed to institutional preservation, enamored by big buildings and valuable property, in love with celebrity pastors, and engaged in mostly passive, representative ministries (i.e., I will put five dollars in the plate to pay someone else to do ministry for me).

It isn't working

Don’t get me wrong, discipleship is a fabulous vision and goal — it simply isn’t working at the moment (and some would say it has never worked very well beyond a handful of the called and chosen). In a nutshell, our current mission is like giving calculus problems to pre-schoolers — way above the cognitive and rational skills of the audience.

We adopted the Great Commission as our mission because we were attempting to say who we thought we should be, not to base our vision in anything feasible or viable. I see four fundamental problems with the adoption of “discipleship” as a denominational mission:

1. Discipleship is hard. When applications designers launch new apps for phones and tablets, they are almost 99.9 percent sure that their end-users will be able to use and benefit from their efforts. They begin with the end-user in mind and create that which will be simple, intuitive, and comfortable.


January 15, 2013

Comments (3)

Comment Feed

Fantastic piece Rev Dan Dick!

You sir have done a fantastic job of presenting your piece with much thought, research and supportive references. You have proposed a much more simplified mission statement that is not "Radical" as the General Conference enforced upon us in 1996. My hope and prayer is that your message will be proposed, enacted and forwarded starting at this summer's annual Conference gathering. You are truley a welcomed voice in the wilderness with keen insight and vision. I stand with you in your call and support your proposed mission statement that makes sense, is clearly stated and best of all is "so do-able"! God bless you Dan.

Ken Miller, Oak Creek UMC, WI more than 1 years ago

Time for a New Mission

What Rev. Dick proposes for a new vision for the UMC is a very appropriate way to go toward the present UMC vision. As Rev. Dick very well develops in his five pages, for our present society, it would be better to define our vision as the manner of how to reach our goal, rather than the goal itself.

Norm Dyer more than 1 years ago

Time for a New Mission

Amen and Bravo!

Tom Griffith more than 1 years ago

Recent Posts


How can we discern God's will for the future of The United Methodist Church? Through United Methodist Insight, leaders and influencers gain a broad vision of the news and views that are shaping the global denomination. Your financial support helps prepare United Methodist leaders for 21st century challenges of faith. Click on the donate button above for online giving. Or make checks payable to St. Stephen UMC and write "UM Insight" on the memo line. Then mail to United Methodist Insight, c/o St. Stephen United Methodist Church, 2520 Oates Drive, Mesquite, TX 75150. Thank you!

Sign up for the weekly compilation of UM Insight original content and articles from multiple sources of interest to the future of The United Methodist Church.
  • Court Decisions

    UMC Trial Courts Have Options

    United Methodist "jurors" have many more options available to them than "not guilty" or "revoke credentials" in a pastor's church trial, writes the Rev. Jerry Eckert.

  • Dallas Wedding

    Supervisory Response Under Way for Rev. McElvaney

    Dallas Area Bishop Michael McKee has confirmed that a "supervisory response" is under way in the complaint against the Rev. Bill McElvaney for officiating at the religious wedding of a gay couple.

  • Washington Mudslide

    United Methodists Ready to Assist After Washington Mudslide

    The Pacific Northwest Conference's emergency response team stands poised to help a devastated community recovery from a massive mudslide, once critical rescue-and-recovery efforts conclude over the widespread and still dangerous debris field.

Built with Metro Publisher™