Responding to Criticisms about Merger vs. Schism

by

by

Comments (1)

Comment Feed

Merger vs. Schism

Hi Jeremy,
i am new to the party! I have only been following the UMC discussion since this website went up during the conference. I thought your article was very well thought out and laid out. However, when you wrote "I believe that we are reflecting our culture now..." that is probably the problem. I don't believe it is ever a good idea for the church--any church or denomination, to let the world influence its message or medium. i live in Washington state and the majority just legalized recreational marijuana, i don't think anyone has thought of it yet, but i am sure that some churches will have to not only have a prayer room, but now a smoking room as well. I do believe that the "gay issue" will probably not be solved on a macro scale with church doctrine, it is too easy in the West right now, for any church from any denomination to "do their own thing" so schism is really not needed at all. I also wonder about the "domino' effect, how can the UMC say it is ok to have openly LGBT clergy but then discipline, suspend or fire heterosexual pastors having affairs, or straight pastors just living with a women? and marriage for LGBT will not solve it, let's me honest, not all LGBT clergy are going to get married or be in a "long term covenant" relationship. Just my 2 cents worth thanks!

Dave more than 2 years ago

Notable Quotes

"Some religious people even insinuated that it was a punishment from God. Others too said different things about the virus till it claimed the lives of thousands of Sierra Leoneans."
United Methodist Bishop John K. Yambasu, in a recent speech when he also said that Sierra Leone will never be fully free until it is free from Ebola virus.


"All of us learn more from mercy than from judgment."
-- Episcopal priest Becca Stevens, founder of Thistle Farms, a redemptive community for women, and author of a new book, Letters From The Farm: A Simple Path for a Deeper Spiritual Life


"It seems the world is beginning to realize that all the hugging and the talk of the poor and vulnerable and the economy is not a papal PR campaign but an authentic call to live a Gospel that might just require the rest of us to (gasp!) change our lives. And that’s making many people uncomfortable."

– Writer Kerry Weber in an article on Pope Francis for the Jesuit magazine America.


"Our culture is so sick. We arm people to the teeth, they destroy lives with hideous disregard, and then political leaders say, 'All we can do now is pray.' That's a cowardly lie."
-- Church historian and author Diana Butler Bass, shared on Facebook