I'm a Christian, Too



Comments (2)

Comment Feed

Is he wrong or not?

It seems to me that you are claiming that he is not a false teacher, but that you believe he is wrong on this issue. It seems to me that he said that progressive teaching would be false. I don't see how he said that anyone wasn't a Christian.

"We have in the church two groups that believe the other group is bringing erroneous or false teaching into the church. Traditionalists believe that to change the definition of marriage from one man and one woman would be to violate the clear teaching of Scripture, including the specific teachings of Jesus on marriage. Such teaching would be false and not true to the Gospel and therefore unacceptable in the church.

Progressives believe that the Bible does not speak about loving, monogamous same-sex relationships, and that the Holy Spirit is showing the church a new way that affirms such relationships as equivalent to marriage in every way. They believe that to discriminate (as they see it) against same-sex attracted persons is a violation of Jesus’ commandment to love one another and is therefore a false teaching that must be changed and repudiated by the church."

Chad 304 days ago

Wrong vs False

Is there a real difference? Does it really matter whether we call each other wrong or false? The United Methodist Church has been having this argument since 1972. Every General Conference since 1972 has ended the argument only for it to keep on going. Bottom line is we do not agree on sexuality or that General Conference is the only thing designated to speak for the whole church. We do not agree on abortion or what our view of Israel should be. And my guess is that as time goes on, the list of disagreements will continue to increase. I have already read the article from a progressive pastor who declares the understanding of God as being of three persons is totally and completely bogus. I also do not believe that a single denomination can be an adequate representative of God when it states that God is and is not for and against something. I do not believe God is double minded, which is exactly what the One Church plan is stating. My bigger view of the church is that the United Methodist Church is one small branch of the holy catholic/universal Church that possess theology in common with every other branch of Christianity while at the same time possesses what I call "lesser theology" that is unique to it. So where do I fit into your picture of it is OK for the UMC to be mired down in theological plurality?

betsy 305 days ago

Notable Quotes   

    "Christ told us specifically where He would be found and where we were to worship Him as Christians until He came in glory: Christ is in the people who need our help. Christ is in hungry and thirsty people; in people without adequate clothing and shelter; in people who are strangers in a strange land and people who are imprisoned. Any so-called Christianity that ignores or, God forbid, abuses such people is pernicious heresy from the pit of hell. You spit on the Body of Christ in the Chalice when you abuse Him in the body of your neighbor."

    – Mary Pezzulo, "How to Help Imprisoned Migrants," on her blog "Steel Magnificat" on Patheos.com.


If you value receiving United Methodist Insight, please contribute to our financial support. Make checks payable to our sponsoring congregation, St. Stephen UMC, and write "UM Insight" on the memo line. Then mail to United Methodist Insight, c/o St. Stephen United Methodist Church, 2520 Oates Drive, Mesquite, TX 75150.

Thank you!

Get United Methodist Insight Weekly!

* indicates required