United Methodist Insight | Kay Kotan | October 27, 2026
Every church wants to see new people discover faith, experience belonging, and become engaged in the life of the congregation. Yet while some churches gain traction in reaching new people, others struggle to reach and retain guests. What if the problem isn’t the quality of your worship, the relevance of your sermons, the friendliness of your hospitality, or the number of programs you offer? What if the problem is your underlying expectation that people should come to you?
Could your church’s approach to ministry be unintentionally keeping you from reaching the very people you are called to serve?
An attractional ministry model assumes that if we offer compelling worship, meaningful programs, or an engaging sermon series, new people will show up. This approach may appeal to people already looking for a church. But what about those who have no church background, feel disconnected from organized religion, or see little reason to walk through our doors?
The World Has Changed. Have Our Expectations?
In 2000, 71% of Americans belonged to a church. By 2020, that number had fallen to 47%, according to Gallup. Generations have now grown up with little or no connection to congregational life. For many people, church is no longer a cultural norm—or even a consideration.
Yet some churches continue to operate as though the community is simply waiting for an invitation to Sunday worship.
Worse, we sometimes judge those who don’t come. We wonder what is wrong with them, why sports take priority on Sundays, or why parents don’t bring their children to church. But what if those judgments reveal more about our assumptions than about our neighbors?
People are finding connection, belonging, and purpose elsewhere. Meanwhile, some churches are perceived as judgmental, cliquish, irrelevant, or untrustworthy.
We cannot build meaningful relationships with people we have already judged, and we cannot reach people we expect to come to us without ever going to them.
Jesus Didn’t Wait for People to Show Up
Jesus offers us a radically different model. He met people in their homes, around tables, along roads, at wells, and in the ordinary places of everyday life. He built relationships, listened to stories, crossed social boundaries, and invited people into a transformed life. He also sent his disciples out to do the same.
Jesus didn’t merely invite people to attend a gathering. He invited them into a relationship and a new way of living.
John Wesley envisioned Methodism as a movement of spiritual fire and community transformation, not simply an institution to maintain. When we spend our energy maintaining our buildings, programs, and internal systems while waiting for outsiders to come in, we risk preserving the church’s structure while neglecting its mission.
From Attraction to Engagement
What would change if your church stopped asking, “How can we get more people to come to us?” and started asking, “How can we go where people already are and build relationships that help them experience Christ?”
Perhaps it means sharing a meal with neighbors, showing up at community events, listening before offering answers, or creating opportunities for genuine relationships beyond Sunday morning. Maybe it means equipping every member to live as a disciple in everyday life—not simply inviting friends to attend a service.
The goal isn’t to abandon Sunday worship. It’s to stop treating attendance as the primary measure of mission.
Church leaders, consider this: Are you building a church that people must come to—or equipping a movement of disciples who go to people?
The future of your ministry may depend less on what happens inside your building and more on what your people do when they leave it.
Where will you lead your congregation to go next?
Kay Kotan is a nationally recognized, credentialed professional coach, church consultant, speaker, and author. Kay is a collaborative partner and equipper for pastors, laity, and congregations to build vibrant discipling faith communities who are transforming lives and communities.
Kay is author and co-author of several books. The latest include:

