Lemuel D. Danganan | Philippine Christian University | November 4, 2026
The Children Know the Steps
Picture a group of children dancing to the beat of a hip-hop-themed song. Every movement appears carefully synchronized with the next (a shoulder turn, a drop to the floor, a rise). The performance is impressive. There are adults sitting, some standing in the back of the room, some with their phones out. The kids move as though the routine has been practiced. The music draws attention, though. The song wasn’t written for these kids. The beat is the beat of the youth of a whole generation of adults now coming to church with their kids. The scene raises the question of whether church programming has gone too far in creating a gulf between the generations, even when they share some cultural memory.
Imagine a dad who knows the old dance but not the new steps, or a mom who remembers dancing as a young person and now sees a child confidently learning new steps. The kid might be the one to teach the adult; the adult might be the one to teach the kid; both might get the steps wrong; or the adult might just be watching and learning. No one should have to pretend to enjoy the same music. The possibility is far more modest and human. The child might discover that the parent who’s giving the instructions at home was once young. The parent might spot something in the child that would never have come out in a normal conversation at the table. One encounter won’t necessarily fix a damaged relationship, but it might well be the beginning of a different relationship.
Church schedules can tell the story before any explanation is offered. Children meet in a separate room; young people attend youth activities; adults attend another program; and older members gather elsewhere. Some of that is entirely appropriate. No church in its right mind would teach a toddler and a teenager as though their needs were the same. It’s quite possible for a church to have a separate program for every age group and yet find that families don’t actually share any experience of church life at all. The report may say little about whether the people actually encountered one another. The Church has a vocation to teach the faith. The way in which people gather must also allow space for the mutual care that is an essential part of the faith.
What Belongs To More Than One Generation
Hip-hop can make this question visible because its history is longer than the childhood of present-day performers. Some members of Generation X encountered it when it was still being contested as a new form of music and dance. Many Millennials grew up with its wider circulation in popular culture, including songs now returning in remixes and contemporary performances.
Children may know the later version of the choreography better than either of the adult generations. The interesting thing is that the older person doesn’t have to be the expert and the younger person doesn’t have to be the one with nothing to offer. If the dance allows for teaching and learning, then the music has achieved something quite modest but quite worthwhile. A space has opened in which both generations can attend to one another.
That concept should never be reduced to a generational stereotype. Not every Gen X person grew up with the same music; not every Millennial did either. The rural/urban divide is real. Musical taste is going to vary from family to family. Religious background and economic circumstances all matter. Not every hip-hop fan will have the same understanding of its history, and a church shouldn’t just borrow the beats without at least acknowledging the people and communities who created that culture. The value of a shared experience lies less in how many people know the song than in the willingness to ask what it means to those who actually know it. A young person coming to a parent with a current dance might be just as acceptable as an adult introducing a dance from an earlier youth.
The issue of authority is actually more difficult than the dance itself. Adults are normally expected to lead; children are expected to learn. That’s often the case, particularly in matters of safety and judgment. It doesn’t follow that the children are in any way irrelevant to the life of the home or the congregation.
A 12-year-old may be the only person in the room who knows that particular step. An older person may have to confess unfamiliarity with the rhythm. Neither party is in any way diminished by the exchange. A child doesn’t gain the moral authority of a parent by teaching a dance and a parent doesn’t lose any standing by learning from a child. For a moment, there is a shift in the balance of who gets to give something. If that exchange is taken seriously, it may well teach the Church to listen before deciding whose voice it wants to hear.
The same principle will require a different expression for the very young kids now known as Generation Beta. Infants and toddlers cannot reasonably be expected to dance like an older hip-hop crew. For the youngest children, a meaningful activity may be a caregiver’s responsive movement, a simple rhythm, a playful gesture, or the sheer joy of being seen. The future Church will not serve Generation Beta by expecting infants and toddlers to perform like older children. Service to Generation Beta begins with opportunities for developmentally appropriate participation, alongside support for the caregivers essential to early development.
A Church Is More Than a Crowd That Enjoys Itself
The word ‘healing’ requires care. A room filled with energetic children, music, movement, and delighted adults may offer a genuine moment of joy. Joy deserves a place in the Christian community, but the presence of joy does not mean that an injured relationship has been repaired or that a frightened child has become safe.
One 2024 randomized study of an online hip-hop program involving 58 adolescents reported improvements in social bonding and well-being relative to a waitlist group. That’s a perfectly reasonable question to ask. The findings don’t, however, give a pastor the right to promise that dancing will cure depression, that a child has overcome trauma, or that a dysfunctional family relationship has been mended. The pleasure of a moment and the repair of a life are not the same thing. One may be real, and the other may be completely empty.
Some kids will have issues that are completely invisible amid a busy, noisy afternoon. One may be concerned about a parent who is unwell. Another may simply lack the funds for the clothes or transportation that the activity demands. Another may not want to be in the room with a particular family member for reasons the church hasn’t quite grasped yet. The room can be full of noise, bright light, and all the smiles in the world, and yet there could be someone in that room who is just terrified. A good church will be able to enjoy the room and still be aware of that possibility. It won’t be in a position to say that a smile is proof of healing or that a refusal to join in the dancing is proof of resistance to God.
Pastoral work very rarely ends in some cathartic, uplifting moment. Grief can come back to the same congregation the very next week. The sick still need pastoral visits even when the medical report has not changed. A grieving family cannot be expected to move on and reconcile according to a church calendar. An activity that brings people together may be quite welcome without it being an opportunity to gloss over the reality of suffering. A child may leave a session in a good mood and return to a very difficult situation at home. That good mood in the afternoon is not the whole of the pastoral response. Ministry may well start with a song, but the real test is what happens afterward.
John Wesley Might Have Objected
There’s a complication that a Methodist writer should bring to the surface rather than just tuck away in a footnote. John Wesley was distinctly critical of public dancing. In ‘The More Excellent Way’, Wesley recognized the need for recreation but felt that some forms of amusements were inconsistent with the gravity of the Christian life. The General Rules were equally clear in their disapproval of diversions that could not properly be called ‘in the name of Christ’. The ‘Wesleyan’ label cannot simply be placed on a hip-hop class as though Wesley had approved. Wesley did not write about a modern-day Philippine church running a supervised dance class. The historical objections are very real, and the Christian purpose of any such present-day practice must be demonstrably there.
That burden does not require treating Wesley’s eighteenth-century account of recreation as a definitive list settling every subsequent question. The type of activity Wesley condemned must be compared with the activity under consideration today. Is it an exercise in display? Does it lead to pressure, embarrassment, or behavior which is contrary to the church’s teaching? Does it take up the very attention which the congregation is supposed to be giving to prayer, worship, and service? Or has the church arranged it so that families can meet, children are treated respectfully, and those who have become isolated can find some company? A Methodist church may well have a very different answer to those questions from another church. What it cannot do is just say ‘the music is popular and the youth enjoy it’ and thereby answer the questions.
Wesley’s three General Rules provide a more demanding way to test the proposal. Do no harm. Do good. Attend upon the ordinances of God. The rules do not turn Zumba into a sacrament or a substitute for Scripture, prayer, preaching, or Holy Communion. The rules ask whether a chosen activity is consistent with the Christian commitments governing life together. A church which puts a vulnerable child on stage without the appropriate safeguards has not fulfilled the first rule, however much the crowd may be cheering. A church that offers isolated parents the opportunity to join a friendship group may well be doing good. A church which allows recreational success to take the place of worship and discipleship has mistaken an occasion for fellowship for the very purpose of the church.
The Methodist class meeting is a perfect example of something which is frequently absent from current debates about community. The early Methodist classes did far more than simply get a group of people together. Members were expected to inquire into one another’s lives, offer practical help, and remain accountable to one another. To romanticize every aspect of eighteenth-century discipline would be wrong, and to imagine that the historic system can be simply restored in its original form would be equally wrong. The point is the degree of seriousness with which fellowship was taken. An event can be a complete success on Saturday and leave absolutely nothing of mutual responsibility by Monday. Wesley would have had every reason to ask whether that meeting in any way had served the life of the society or had merely been an occasion for occupying an hour.
The Children Are Not a Publicity Campaign
There’s another danger in a successful youth event. The event is so successful that the children become a convenient image of the church the congregation hopes to become. A promotional image may attract attention. The church may begin counting views, shares, attendance, and prospective members. The numbers can show an audience’s reach but cannot reveal whether a reluctant child was pressured into participating or whether photographs were shared with appropriate consent. The same numbers reveal nothing about the child sitting in the back or the family unable to afford transportation. When a church is talking about renewal, it has to be very careful not to put the onus of its publicity on the children.
Kant’s familiar requirement never to treat people merely as means applies directly here. A child is not a prop for a great photograph. A child who is moving with confidence is no more of a human being than one who is stumbling, watching from the side, or needing an accessible option. A parent’s desire for a child’s success does not settle questions of public exposure, embarrassment, or consent. A church claiming to be a place of care must ask what children actually experience, given the responsibilities adults properly bear toward children.
Any pastor familiar with ministry reports will know how a good program can quite easily take on a second life. It’s a family event; photos are taken, and the best are then used as proof of the ministry’s progress. That process in itself is perfectly legitimate. The problem comes when the people in the photos are then treated as if the congregation owns the photographs and they are available for unrestricted use. Consent to take part in an event doesn’t in any way equate to consent to the uncontrolled circulation of a person’s photograph. A parent may have a reason for not wanting a child’s picture published. The child may have a reason that hasn’t yet been considered. The purpose for which records are kept, the length of time records are kept, and the extent of their circulation all need to be justified, particularly when the child is so young that the child cannot reasonably understand the consequences of the photograph going out into the world.
Whose Culture Is Invited Into The Room?
A church also has to consider which culture is being imported when hip-hop enters the fellowship hall. The music didn’t just pop up out of nowhere as a potential tool of ministry. It has a history of its own, including specific communities, artists, public debates, and experiences that are far more than just a footnote. Some songs will simply not be appropriate for a church congregation. Others may be perfectly fine as part of a normal recreational session and in no way be a form of worship. The decision should be one of care rather than one of panic or quick approval. The lyrics need to be heard, the participants’ ages need to be taken into account, the artists and communities need to be respected, and copyright clearances need to be obtained before any reproduction or public release. Bringing a song into the fellowship hall is not an opportunity to just erase that song’s history.
The questions remain if the congregation chooses Zumba, folk dance, gospel music, or another form of movement. Is it actually inclusive of people from all walks of life? Does it require expensive shoes, lessons, or transportation, which would effectively exclude a family of modest means? Can people take part without having bodies scrutinized and measured against a single standard? Is the teaching appropriate for children at various stages of development? Can the church listen to a parent who is uncomfortable with the music and not regard that as a challenge to the young people? A program which thoughtfully addresses these issues may not be the one that wins over the online audience. It may very well be the one that actually builds a community that people can trust.
Space must be available for people whose bodies don’t allow for, or who prefer not to, perform the expected movements. Disability is not an argument against shared participation. It is an argument against the idea that participation can be defined only to exclude anyone who isn’t a confident performer. A participant might keep the beat with a hand, choose the music, help with event logistics, lead the discussion afterward, or simply watch. A child who chooses to just watch is not a failed dancer. An older person who can’t stand for long periods is not an obstacle to a successful program. The Church speaks of the dignity of the individual. That has to be a real thing when the choreography is different, when a different activity is chosen, or indeed when there is no dancing at all.
Sources and Further Reading
Danganan, L. D. (2021). Duty to love or Agape-Deon: Towards a human rights framework of the Philippine Church [Doctoral dissertation, Philippine Christian University].
Kant, I. (1785). Groundwork of the metaphysics of morals. Humanity formulation, Academy edition 4:429.
O'Neill, O. (2010). Rights, obligations, priorities. Studies in Christian Ethics, 23(2), 163–171. https://doi.org/10.1177/0953946809359468
Tunçgenç, B., Greig, E.-J., & Cohen, E. (2024). Benefits of an online group dance program for adolescents' social bonding and wellbeing. Journal of Adolescence, 96(8), 1917–1928. https://doi.org/10.1002/jad.12391
Wesley, J. (1743). The nature, design, and general rules of the United Societies.
Wesley, J. (1787). The more excellent way (Sermon 89, Section V).
Wolterstorff, N. (2008). Justice: Rights and wrongs. Princeton University Press.
Wolterstorff, N. (2011). Justice in love. William B. Eerdmans Publishing Company.
Wolterstorff, N. (2017). Love as care: A brief definition of love. Biola University Center for Christian Thought.
Biblical Texts
The Holy Bible: Luke 15:25–32; 1 Corinthians 12.
Lemuel D. Danganan is a pastor-teacher and an adjunct professor at Philippine Christian University. Research areas include Christian ethics, philosophy of religion, human dignity, and the responsibilities of religious institutions.


