United Methodist Insight | Rebekah Simon-Peter | October 27, 2026
The United Methodist Church is facing some hard realities. Declining membership. Aging congregations. Shrinking budgets. Fewer clergy. Church closures. Annual conferences struggling to maintain inherited structures and ministries.
None of this is new.
The denomination was already experiencing decades of decline when disaffiliation began. Between 2019 and 2023, roughly one-quarter of United Methodist congregations in the United States left the denomination. Losing more than 7,600 churches intensified the decline.
And while disaffiliation may have largely run its course, the underlying pattern of decline has not.
Annual conferences are increasingly sharing bishops through newly configured episcopal areas. In 2024, the number of active U.S. bishops was reduced from 39 to 32. Many now oversee multiple annual conferences across larger geographical areas. My own bishop oversees four massive western states: Montana, Utah, Wyoming, and Colorado, plus a smidgen of Idaho.
Bottom line, bishops are stretched thinner even as the challenges they face have multiplied.
At the same time, there are encouraging signs. United Methodist leaders from around the world recently met in Calgary for a Council of Bishops Leadership Gathering, "Emboldened by the Spirit: Imagining a Church Yet to Be."
It may be exactly what our denomination needs.
But here's the question that must be asked.
Can a denomination whose decisions are increasingly shaped by decline actually enact widespread renewal?
Possibly. But only if we begin thinking differently about what renewal requires.
When Management Replaces Vision
Church strategist Rev. Dr. George Bullard, Jr., identified 10 predictable stages in a congregation's life cycle. He also identified four factors that shape a church's development: vision, relationships, programs, and management.
As congregations mature, vision gradually gives way to management. Maintaining what exists takes precedence over envisioning what comes next. Eventually, survival becomes the primary concern.
Over the last 15 years, I've seen this pattern repeatedly in my Creating a Culture of Renewal® leadership development cohorts. In churches large and small; in urban, rural and suburban settings; in congregations of diverse racial and ethnic backgrounds; in a dozen different denominations.
I can’t help but wonder if the same thing is happening at the denominational level. Are the very structures designed to manage decline now limiting our capacity to envision renewal?
Renewal Is Not the Same as Reorganization
Over the last few months, I've led DARE to Dream Like Jesus visioning workshops in annual conferences that have undergone significant district restructuring. District boundaries and responsibilities had changed so much that even district superintendents struggled to keep track.
I'm not criticizing these leaders or these decisions. Restructuring may have been necessary. But it raises a larger concern. When so much energy goes into reorganizing the church, how much is left for envisioning its future?
Reorganization does not equal renewal.
A new district map doesn't give us a new vision. Nor does a more efficient structure automatically produce vital congregations.
Renewal begins with vision. Not a vision statement that gets approved at annual conference and then filed away. Not a strategic plan that simply projects current trends into the future.
I'm talking about a Jesus-like Dream that calls us beyond what we already know how to do or know how to fund. A dream that expands our assumptions about what is possible. A dream that speaks to the needs of the communities we serve. A dream larger than our current resources or capacities. A dream that frightens us a little.
That's the kind of dream Jesus offered when he prayed: Thy kingdom come, Thy will be done, on earth as it is in heaven.
Jesus didn't organize his ministry around preserving the religious institutions of his day. He proclaimed the kingdom of God. He invited people into a future that did not yet exist. He gathered disciples, equipped them to be apostles, and sent them out to participate in God's transforming work.
What might happen if denominational visioning began there?
Waiting Is Not Preparing
When I invited leaders in these conferences to dream larger, I encountered a familiar response.
"Maybe we should wait until the new district superintendent arrives."
"This bishop is on the way out. The new one won't be here for another year. Let’s hold off on any decisions until then."
I've heard variations of this response for years: "Let's wait until we have a new Director of Connectional Ministries or Leadership Development, or until redistricting is complete."
Congregations say much the same when waiting for the next pastor. And pastors say it when waiting for a new slate of lay leaders.
On the surface, waiting seems reasonable, even respectful. Why make decisions that someone new will have to live with? Why not give the incoming leader a chance to settle in and determine the direction?
Here's what happens when we wait.
Decline doesn't wait with us.
While we postpone decisions, congregations continue to lose members, resources diminish, and opportunities pass. The longer we wait, the more risk-averse people become. By the time the new leader arrives, there's even less appetite for change.
Meanwhile, we've placed the responsibility for reversing decline on someone who wasn't there when we decided to wait. Depending on how long a system has been in decline, it can take four to seven years to create lasting renewal.
What was intended as a courtesy becomes another obstacle to renewal.
Waiting for new leadership is not the same as preparing for new leadership.
Think about John the Baptist. He didn't simply announce that someone greater was coming and then sit back and wait for Jesus to arrive. Instead, he got busy. He preached repentance, baptized people, and challenged their assumptions. He engaged people in the renewal of faith.
What if we approached leadership transitions the same way?
Instead of waiting for the next district superintendent or bishop to arrive before beginning the work of renewal, what if we started preparing the way now? New leaders would inherit a community already engaged in renewal, rather than having to start from scratch.
Let Vision Make the Decisions
Imagine an annual conference preparing its budget for the coming year.
The conversation typically begins with projected income, existing obligations, and anticipated shortfalls. Leaders work to balance the numbers while minimizing the damage.
But what if the conversation began somewhere else?
What if leaders first asked: What is God's vision for the communities we are called to serve? What kind of churches and leaders will that future require? What must we begin investing in now to make that future possible?
The financial realities and difficult decisions would remain. But a different future would guide them.
Instead of asking only which ministries we could afford to maintain, we might ask which ministries will help bring God's vision to life.
Instead of focusing primarily on how many churches are declining, we might ask how we can create the conditions for congregations to renew.
Instead of measuring what we preserve, we might measure the new life emerging.
This isn't wishful thinking. It's a different approach to leadership.
When vision makes the decisions, even difficult choices can serve a hopeful future.
Planning for Widespread Renewal
Widespread renewal must become more than a congregational initiative. It must shape denominational culture.
That means developing emotionally intelligent leaders who can envision, lead and implement change, even with pushback and resistance. It means investing in congregations willing to take risks. It means aligning appointments, budgets, leadership development, and conference priorities with an expanded vision for the future.
I hope the Calgary conversations inspire bishops and conference leaders to return home ready to turn vision into action.
Because imagining a church yet to be is only the beginning. The real work is bringing that church to life.
Denominational leaders must model the courage, creativity, faith, and willingness to change that we ask of our local churches.
That way, instead of asking congregations to renew within a system managing decline, we would begin to create a denominational culture of renewal.
The Future Is Still Being Created
I don't underestimate the challenges facing the United Methodist Church. The losses are real. The grief is real. The financial pressures are real.
But so is God's capacity to make all things new.
Through the prophet Isaiah, God declares, "I am about to do a new thing; now it springs forth, do you not perceive it?" (Isaiah 43:19)
Perhaps that's the invitation before us now.
Not to deny decline. Not to avoid difficult decisions. Not to pretend that every congregation or institution can continue as it has.
But to stop allowing decline to be the organizing principle of our future.
The United Methodist Church can do more than manage its losses. It can envision a future worth investing in, develop leaders to bring it to life, and align its resources with that vision.
Can a denomination in decline plan for widespread renewal?
Yes.
But first, we have to decide that renewal, not decline, will guide our decisions.
Rebekah Simon-Peter is a United Methodist Clergyperson living in Casper, Wyoming.
Rebekah is the author of several books. The most recent is Believe Like Jesus.

