Ghosts, Witches, and Apparitions (Happy Halloween through a Wesleyan Lens)
Ghosts, Witches, Apparitions. There was a time when Wesley was particularly interested in what we might call paranormal phenomena. And he made some interesting spiritual connections. He corresponded with family about ghosts in his childhood home. One was even given a name – Old Jeffery. John was away at school at the time but trusted that there was something to the stories. In addition, he spoke of people who believed they were possessed by the devil and received deliverance through prayer. He heard other stories with caution but not dismissal. Then comes the leap, where this interest led to a critique of the Enlightenment.
Wesley laments how “men of learning” had “given up all accounts of witches and apparitions.” To do so, in his reasoning, is also a step away from giving up the Bible. If they admit any “intercourse with separate spirits,” then “their whole castle in the air (Deism, Atheism, Materialism) falls to the ground.” Wesley does what he does so often. He tries to find middle ground between extremes. In his Journals, as he reviews a book about apparitions, Wesley admits how hard (and necessary) it is “to keep the middle way; not to believe too little or too much!”
As incarnate beings, our healthiest place is along the middle way. Wesley uses this image often. He says that a primary function of the Holy Spirit is to help us “steer a middle course” between the extremes of enthusiasm and formality, to use his words. At one extreme, we confuse our opinions with the voice of God, and at the other extreme we have the form of religion without the power. We dismiss possibilities that might open our hearts to God. In another place, Wesley speaks of the middle way between the extremes of undervaluing and overvaluing reason (which is relevant to this discussion). At one extreme, we dismiss reason to believe in all kinds of extraordinary displays. At the other extreme, we turn from the possibility that there is more than what is before us and thus miss out on much. And here, as Wesley speaks of ghosts and apparitions, he warns us of the extremes of overfocusing on other-worldly realities and, at the other extreme, dismissing such possibilities altogether. May we not steer a middle course to the glory of God. (There will be more in future posts about the middle way).
Wesley never mentioned Halloween, but reading between the lines, it is possible to draw some connections – and find some inspiration. Wesley continued to celebrate All Saints' Day and even made a point of saying it was a festival he dearly loved. In England at the time, many Protestants had moved away from this observance, with concerns about prayers for the dead and the veneration of saints. In Scotland and Ireland, however, the festival continued and grew. Hallowtide was a multiday festival that included All Hallows’ Eve – the day before All Hallows’ Day – where traditions included ringing bells for the dead, lighting candles, and going house to house where “soul cakes” were given in exchange for prayers for the dead. Wesley held on to a part of this tradition. He believed that this day, and our faith more generally, gives us a rich language to describe things beyond this world – angels, demons, spirits, resurrection, eternal life, heaven, and the victory over death itself.
The lens of the middle way offers insight into how we might approach Halloween in a healthy way. It is good to open our hearts to a larger reality – and to find fun ways to make the connections. With the grandeur of all creation, where galaxies are counted in the trillions, where atoms are 99% space – at least in terms of what we observe – and where our senses can only register small portions of possible spectrums, how can we possibly believe that “this” is all there is? All creation points to so much more. Our faith leads us to believe that all is known and loved. While we can overfocus on such things, even to the point of causing harm, at the other extreme is to believe that there is nothing beyond what we can observe with our finite senses and that there are things in the universe that are never known and loved. How sad it is to think that we are the ultimate end of all knowledge and love. Or we might use the word “arrogant.”
Wesley was not big on games – or any distractions from holiness. At the same time, I believe it is fair to say, in the spirit of the middle way, that community traditions, festivals, and games can be redeemed, especially when they are rooted in faith and when we are open to connections and inspiration from beyond. In Wesleyan fashion, we might say that traditions of silly costumes, candy, and ghost stories can make all of this fun, as a part of the larger connection. With this hope, I am pleased to say to all, “Happy Halloween!”
Notes and a Deeper Dive
The quote referencing the middle way is found in Wesley’s Journals, May 28, 1768. The middle way here lies between the extremes of an enthusiasm eager to believe sensational stories and a skepticism unwilling to entertain such possibilities at all. Wesley used the term in “infidelity” or “infidels” to describe deists and others who actively dismissed notions of miracles, spirits, or revelations from beyond. As used today, it is not the most flattering term. In denying principalities and powers beyond what is before our senses, we lose some of the “magic” and “mystery” of being human – and this is my language. Wesley’s big concern was that such skepticism or infidelity renders much of Scripture irrelevant. Again, the middle way is key, where we avoid both skepticism and sensationalism. For a direct quote: "The English in general, and indeed most of the men of learning in Europe, have given up all accounts of witches and apparitions as mere old wives' fables. I am sorry for it... The giving up witchcraft is in effect giving up the Bible." Journal: May 25, 1768
For another quote, “When old Dr. A——r was asked, what her disorder was, he answered, “It is what formerly they would have called being bewitched.” And why should they not call it so now? Because the infidels have hooted witchcraft out of the world; and the complaisant Christians, in large numbers, have joined with them in the cry…[This] manner of speaking concerning witchcraft must be extremely offensive to every sensible man, who cannot give up his Bible.” Journal: July 4, 1770.
Michael Roberts
Michael Roberts has served as a pastor, a director of conference ministries, a delegate to General Conference, a retreat leader, and a teacher of United Methodist history and doctrine. He is married with three grown children and two grandchildren. He likes to take time each day to write and play guitar as a part of his devotional life. He is the author of four books based on John Wesley sermons which can be found at marketsquarebooks.com.

