United Methodist Insight | Jason Stanley | November 4, 2026
Whenever I ask church leaders about their vision, someone points to the bulletin, a framed statement on the wall, a list of forgotten goals, or a dusty strategic plan in a notebook. They understand the importance of a vision. The congregation knows it needs direction, purpose, and a sense of where it's going. The language of vision has become a natural part of the church lexicon.
I wonder as we accustom ourselves to the lexicon of vision, whether we've forgotten how to discern.
We need a vision
Let me be clear: we need vision. A local church’s vision is a simple, clear statement that motivates forward movement. It reflects God’s call on the church to reach the people in its community. Leaders can establish achievable goals that bring the vision to life.
We also need discernment. Discernment invites us to listen for where God is leading us. In the discernment process, we engage our imaginations to dream what might be possible, even when we cannot imagine how it would happen. Discernment requires us to slow down as we seek God’s vision, not our own, for the church.
And perhaps that is precisely what the church needs right now.
Many congregations are spending an enormous amount of time talking about and focusing on what they have lost:
- Declining membership
- Shrinking budgets
- Building maintenance
- Less volunteers
These, and others like them, are real challenges, and we should acknowledge them as such. But when we become uber-focused on these challenges, we limit our imagination. We make decisions based on what we no longer have.
John Wesley's thoughts
John Wesley taught that God’s grace is continually at work in our lives, transforming us in love, pulling us closer and closer to being like Christ. This is the work of sanctification, which is not limited to individuals. Sanctification is communal work, challenging the church to continually examine itself.
We believe the Holy Spirit is at work guiding, challenging, and inviting us into new, unimaginable possibilities. At some point, we stopped asking, “How is God calling us?” Perhaps it is because we have become so focused on managing the challenges and crises before us that we have forgotten to seek the Holy Spirit's guidance.
Scripture reminds us that God invites people to imagine possibilities beyond their immediate circumstances. Abraham is invited to look at the stars and imagine descendants beyond what is possible to count. Moses is called to deliver people out of slavery to an unimaginable future. Esther courageously approaches the king, risking her own life, to save her people. Despite her own hesitations, Mary agrees to unexpectedly carry the Son of God.
When we allow ourselves to imagine the unimaginable, we enter into Christian discernment. Discernment begins with listening to God, each other, and our communities. It also requires courage to imagine beyond our comfort zones. Discernment can be uncomfortable when the Holy Spirit challenges our assumptions and our beloved ministries that may no longer serve the mission. Discernment invites us to let go of the comfortable and open ourselves to God’s new creation.
Church leaders have asked me countless times, “What do we need to do to get more people in worship?” I like to turn that question around by asking, “How is God calling you to make disciples?” Or, “How is God calling you to make your community a better place?”
The role of the Holy Spirit
When we seek the Holy Spirit's guidance in discerning what is next, we shift from institutional survival to missional possibility. At our best, the church is a movement. From the days of the Wesley brothers, we have been a movement that met people where they were and started schools and hospitals to meet their needs. It invites us to reclaim who we are as United Methodists at a time when others will not dare do so, to be in ministry with those outside the church walls and in our communities. As Mary before us, we carry the Incarnated Christ into the places and spaces where Chris is needed most.
Before a church needs a new vision statement, it needs to be willing to discern and imagine with the Holy Spirit what the future could be; a future they cannot yet fully realize.
We believe God is already at work in our churches and communities, and the best thing we can do is slow down and discern how we can join God in that work. When Jacob awoke from his dream where he wrestled with God, he declared, “The Lord is in this place, and I did not know it.” God is in our communities, where possibilities beyond our imaginations can reach people who have not yet been reached. But we will never discover those possibilities if we are unwilling to discern.
It is time for the church to stop asking what is realistic given what we have right now and to start discerning what is possible when we trust the God who has been, is, and will be at work in our communities. Thankfully, the future of the church is not limited to what we can imagine.
Jason Stanley is Director of Call & Candidacy for the Virginia Annual Conference. He is an accredited coach through the International Coaching Federation and a certified church consultant. Jason co-authored An Effective Approach to Cooperative Parishes with Kay Kotan.
Contact Jason at jasonstanley@vaumc.org.

