UM Insight | Paul Seay | October 26, 2026
Megan’s call to pastoral ministry
Megan is a junior in college. She lives on campus even though the large university she attends is in her hometown. Since beginning college, Megan has become involved in the Wesley Foundation and remained active in her local United Methodist congregation. One day, Megan texts her pastor: “Hi Pastor Randy. Can we meet for coffee? I have something big I’ve been wrestling with.”
Pastor Randy responds: “Sure! Where do you want to meet and what time?”
“Can you come to the coffee shop in the student center tomorrow morning at 10:00?”
“That works! See you then.”
They arrive at the same time and make small talk while waiting in line. They order their coffee and sit down in the corner. The sound of the espresso machine and chatty, caffeinated students, along with the background music, is just what Megan wants. With all the noise, no one will overhear what she’s about to say.
“I think I might be called to be a pastor,” she hears herself say. She’s not really told anyone, so the sound of the words surprises her as they come out of her mouth.
Pastor Randy is thrilled. He’s not surprised. Megan is a leader in campus ministry and in the church. She’s been a liturgist for traditional worship, sung with the praise band in the contemporary service, and worked with youth and children’s ministries. She has a great sense of humor and has wisdom beyond her years. Above all, Megan is devoted to Jesus and to loving her neighbors in Jesus’ name.
He affirms all of this to her.
“Megan, I definitely see in you someone who has the gifts and calling for pastoral ministry. I will be happy to support you and help guide you as you take your next steps.”
Megan asks, “What are those next steps? What do I do? How exactly do I become a pastor?”
“Well,” Pastor Randy says, “I’ll get you in touch with our District Superintendent so that you can get set up with our District Committee on Ministry. I’ll also ask the chair of our Staff Parish Relations Committee to call a meeting to meet with you. You’ll meet with the committees and the DS. Then, hopefully, you’ll be on your way.”
And, so it begins.
Megan begins the candidacy journey. Soon she’ll be a certified candidate and applying to seminary.
A year later, Megan graduates and moves seven hours away to begin seminary. The Conference Board of Ordained Ministry will oversee her path through seminary to ordination.
Megan’s church is so proud of her. Over the next three years, they will send cards, pray for her, and charter a bus to come to her commissioning service at Annual Conference. They are excited to see what God does through her ministry in the coming decades. This will always be her home church.
Carl: The second career path
Carl has been a middle school teacher and coach for twenty years. He and his wife have two teenage sons. They are faithful United Methodist Christians. The boys have gone through confirmation and are active in the youth group. Carl and his wife are part of a vibrant Sunday school class. Carl shares teaching responsibilities for the class and also leads a men’s small group.
About two years ago, Carl began to feel like God was calling him to pastoral ministry. At first, he kept it to himself. Then he talked with his wife about it. She also sensed that God was up to something new in Carl’s life. Last month, Carl asked his small group to pray about this with him. After a few weeks, the group told Carl that they affirmed his calling. They think he would make a wonderful pastor.
So, Carl reaches out to his pastor. They agree to stay after worship and talk in the pastor’s office. Carl shares about what has been stirring in his spirit and the conversations he’s had with his wife and the small group. His pastor doesn’t hesitate. He sees it too. Carl is gifted and clearly called to this.
What’s next?
Carl meets with the Staff-Parish Relations Committee, the District Superintendent, and the District Committee. He starts candidacy. Within a year, he will do the unthinkable. He will step away from teaching and become a full-time seminary student. The seminary is four hours from where Carl and his family live, so this will mean living away from home Monday through Friday and returning home on the weekends.
Fast forward three years. Carl is graduating from seminary with a solid GPA. His family has made it through this challenging season. Both sons have graduated from high school. In a few weeks, Carl will be commissioned as a provisional member of the Annual Conference and receive his first pastoral appointment. For the first time in almost twenty-five years, Carl and his wife will be moving. Preparing to sell the house where they raised their children has been a deeply emotional endeavor. But even as they look back on the past with gratitude, they are filled with hope for the future.
Different stories, one big thing in common
These two stories are representative of the path into ministry taken by a lot of pastors. On the surface, they look quite different.
Megan is just getting started with her adult life. The call to ministry comes not so much as a disruption but the next step on a journey. She may have had other career plans when she began college, but college students’ plans and aspirations typically change several times during their student years.
Carl’s life, however, has been turned upside down in many ways. He is changing careers, leaving a steady paycheck for three years. He will be apart from his family during seminary. And ultimately, he and his wife will be leaving their home of over two decades when Carl begins his first pastoral appointment.
For all their differences, Carl’s and Megan’s stories have one thing in common, which is often overlooked. When they respond to God’s call to become a pastor, Megan and Carl end up leaving their local church rather quickly.
Not long after becoming certified candidates, they move away to go to seminary. Then, after three short years, they become part of the life of a new local church. Their home church will become a thing of the past, the community that launched them into ministry but with whom they will no longer be in ministry.[1]
Questioning the typical journey
As United Methodists, we have long taken for granted that the call to pastoral ministry entails leaving, as quickly as possible, one’s local church, leaving the community where the calling was first heard and nurtured, first to go to school and then to practice ministry in a different church. Ministry is something done “out there.” And in order to get to where ministry happens, we have to get away from home. That’s just the way it is. That’s the path we follow. Perhaps it gets us ready for a life of itineracy. So, we say.
Maybe, though, it’s time to ask about what is lost in this typical journey from laity to clergy. When we move from being members of our home church to members of the Annual Conference, what gets left behind? Is this pattern potentially bad for both pastors and local churches?
What’s lost? Among other things, we lose actual connection with the local church, leadership and learning opportunities, and strong leaders for the local church. Let’s look at each of these.
Actual connection with the local church
The connection a person has with their local church, the literal connection, is lost. They move away. They no longer worship or serve in person in their local church on any regular basis. There’s an empty seat in their Sunday school class where they used to sit. Someone will have to take their place as a chaperone on youth trips. The Thursday morning prayer group must find a new leader. They don’t pass the peace or share Holy Communion on Sundays with the church family in which their faith grew so deeply over the years. They physically lose and are lost to their local church.
Why is this a big deal? Won’t they attend chapel services at seminary or serve as a ministry intern in a nearby church? Yes, and both of these can be wonderful. You can hear some great sermons from professors in seminary chapel, and internships will give you ministry opportunities you might not have had otherwise. But these experiences should supplement the ministry of the local rather than replace it. Why does it matter? Because the years when budding pastors need the ministry of their local church most are often the years when they are farthest from it.
Leadership and learning opportunities
Candidates for ministry lose opportunities to begin practicing pastoral ministry in their local church. What if the first sermons, visits, and pastoral leadership roles could be among the people who first affirmed a pastor’s calling?[2] What better way to learn to preach and lead authentically than with those who already know you well? You wouldn’t have to step into a new setting and pretend to be a pastor all of a sudden. Instead, what if you could begin to grow into your gifts and graces in the garden where you were already flourishing? If our call is to follow Jesus by caring for the church as pastors, why do we assume candidates can only do that by caring for a church other than their own?
Strong leaders within local churches Local churches lose strong leaders more abruptly than they should have to. It’s not just that a local church has helped the future pastor grow as a disciple and find their calling. In addition to the church having poured into the candidate, the candidate has also poured into the life of the church. Why should the first move be to take a gifted and growing leader away from a church?[3] What if they could stay and continue to grow and minister in ways that would bear fruit for the church and for their future pastoral ministry?
A different (intentionally more provocative) way to look at it
If you’re still not convinced that there might be a problem, here’s another way to look at the way we typically guide people toward becoming a pastor:
A dedicated church member comes to her pastor. She’s excited and nervous about what God may be calling her to. The pastor’s response? “That’s great that you feel called to ministry. The best thing you can do is go away. You can be in ministry, but you have to do that somewhere else. We realize that this is the church that helped you learn what it means to trust and follow Jesus, and it was here that you discerned this calling, so the next step is to begin to cut ties with this church. The district, seminary, and Conference will take it from here. We’ll miss you and pray for you. Goodbye.”
It sometimes seems like the fastest ticket out of a local church is candidacy for ordained ministry.
Unite the pair so long disjoined
The path to pastoral ministry, as we currently practice it, leaves the local church behind. It too often takes the local church away from candidates and candidates from the local church in ways that potentially hurt them both. Instead of immediately outsourcing pastoral training and formation to seminaries (or the Conference), what if we took our first steps a little more slowly? What if we let emerging pastoral leaders linger and lead in their own local churches? Could local churches become (again?) incubators for pastoral ministry?
Emerging pastors and the local churches that sent them into ministry need each other. How might we find ways to keep them together longer? [4]
[1] Yes, they will be in ministry through the larger UMC connection, but their days of local ministry together are over.
[2] More than just preaching on student Sunday or occasionally when the pastor is on vacation.
[3] I recognize that as United Methodists we share resources. We are a connectional church, and one of the ways we live out our connectionalism is sharing pastors. My questions are not coming from a place of scarcity. If anything, I worry that our haste in getting candidates out of local churches represents a sense of scarcity around the availability of pastors.
[4] Nearly everything I’ve said here about the journey from laity toward ordination as an elder could be said about the path taken by most local pastors. While local pastors don’t always go to seminary or relocate away from the community in which they live, they are still dislodged from their home church quite quickly in order to fulfill their call to ministry. I think we should ask the same questions of this paradigm as I have here about the journey from local church to seminary to ordination. Why is getting people out of their local church our go-to move?
Paul Seay has served as a delegate to the 2020/2024 General Conference and is co-author of From Heaven to Earth: Christmas for new believers, old believers, and non-believers. Paul is the pastor of Abingdon United Methodist Church and Charles Wesley United Methodist Church on Main Street in Abingdon, Virginia.
[1] 2026 COB Leadership Gathering will be held in Calgary | UMC.org
[2] 2026 COB Leadership Gathering will be held in Calgary | UMC.org
[3] "Lead Courageously" webinar on ecclesiology | ResourceUMC
[4] Trinity United Methodist Church - Greeneville, Tennessee
[5] The Gathering | One Church Multiple Locations | Church Near Me | St Louis | Webster | Clayton | McCausland
[6] Open Hearts United Methodist Church
[8] Yes, a youth minister, too. But that might wait a year or two as the renewal takes form and the children’s ministry grows.
[9] This is not to diminish the faithful ministry of local pastors. It’s simply to show how things have changed for this church.

