Why the Hobby Lobby Ruling Spells Disaster for Christians

by

by

Comments (7)

Comment Feed

CONTRACEPTIVE DECISION

Some of the interpretations from the left of this decision strike me as a bit bizarre. The Supreme Court didn't say that Hobby Lobby style companies can discriminate in hiring of people based on their contraceptive practices, and it didn't say that employees of those companies can't use contraceptives, including post facto type contraceptives, if they choose. It just said that those companies don't have to pay for those kinds of contraceptives if they object on religious grounds.

LONNIE D BROOKS more than 3 years ago

Hobby Lobby

Hardly a disaster for Christians. Just the opposite. To say the Supreme Court violated the first amendment with this ruling does not pass the smell test. The Court has always treated the First amendment with great respect. The owners of Hobby Lobby did not ask for relief from providing all methods of contraception, only those four out of 20 that in their view crossed the line into abortion. Since there is no equivalent for men comparing women’s health coverage to men’s is ridiculous. Seven of the nine justices agreed that for profit companies are covered by the Religious Freedom Restoration Act. Forcing someone into paying and supporting procedures against their religious beliefs might have crossed with the first amendment. The procedures in question are still legal and these women can still go out and procure them if the other 16 methods are unsuitable for them. Freedom has been preserved not limited.
I have never heard of a religion called anti-abortion Christianity. I see no way you can say that this decision favors this made up religion. It in no way harms the pro-abortion UMC. As for privacy, that went out the window when the affordable health care act was passed. Privacy was sacrificed since the basic premise is that the employer provides health care. We will all soon be in one database or another and who knows who will have access to our personal health data?
As to the long term ramifications of the Hobby Lobby decision, only time will tell.

Kevin more than 3 years ago

Hobby Lobby's position is not supported by fact

Instead, the objection to certain birth control methods is a smokescreen to their efforts to seek to supersede an employer's right to control employees. It is none of this hypocritical billion dollar business entity's business what if anything employees use for birth control. This is an anti-Christian position. The corporation pays nothing for the employees' birth control - it is merely included in insurance, which is an entirely rational law. Hypocrites like the right-wing Hobby Lobby damage Christianity with their labeling of themselves as such and the corporate media's lapping it up as they spin it. People will say "If that's what it means to be Christian, count me out." Privacy? Did the woman Jesus saved from stoning have any privacy from her illiterate self-righteous neighbors? The long term ramifications will be a lowering of the respect for Christianity and a boost for political candidates who run against the extreme right wing judges on the court who delivered this atrocity.

George Nixon Shuler more than 3 years ago

Hobby Lobby

Insurance companies for self insured companies pay nothing. Every dime of health care cost comes from the owners of Hobby Lobby. The insurance company simply administers the health plan. The court has ruled on the constitutionality of this. Liberty has been preserved.

Kevin more than 3 years ago

Privacy?

Anyone who has health care insurance from any source has already long since sacrificed privacy. Most Americans have no hope of privacy if anyone but themselves pays for health insurance. EVen then the facts of one's health care are usually available

Anne more than 3 years ago

Hobby Lobby decision

For the most part, I agree with Cynthia Astle’s prognosis but do not believe this ruling will have the far reaching effect she believes it has. First, Christianity is a multi-disciplined and multi-defined entity in our diverse world today. Just as Judaism and Muslim beliefs are wide and varied in definition and practice, so is Christianity. Second, I do believe an employer needs to provide income for his or her employees, but in this new era of the Affordable Care Act, paid employer health care insurance for employees may be in its twilight years, if not twilight months. Third, just as justice-caring Christians disagreed with Nestle’s policies on infant formula in Third World Countries years ago, they made their voices known by a national boycott that threatened the very existence of the company. Because of their employment health-care insurance policies, I have boycotted Hobby Lobby and invite justice-caring Christians nationally to join in a boycott of Hobby Lobby not only for their health-care insurance policies against the reproductive practices of women, but also their continued purchase of cheap goods from a repressive country that provides little for their citizens employed by companies that place profits over humanness. Unfortunately, this win for a repressive company claiming a Christian base may only be the beginning of other judicial decisions that will mirror such repression in other ways.

Dan Gangler more than 3 years ago

Hatred!

We must all learn to reject hatred. If we all want peace, then peace will come.

Roger Crane more than 3 years ago

Notable Quotes


Brian McLaren"All of us, especially people of faith, need to proclaim that white supremacy and white privilege and all other forms of racism and injustice must indeed be replaced with something better – the beloved community where all are welcome, all are safe, and all are free. White supremacist and Nazi dreams of apartheid must be replaced with a better dream – people of all tribes, races, creeds, and nations learning to live in peace, mutual respect, and neighborliness. Such a better world is possible, but only if we set our hearts on realizing the possibility."

– Brian McLaren, writing in "What I Saw in Charlottesville" on the Auburn Seminary website.


"The idea of racial (or most any other) supremacy is antithetical to that Gospel. We should remember that Jesus himself grasped for no superiority, no rank, but instead made himself a servant, giving himself in love. What we saw in Charlottesville was therefore a kind of anti-gospel, something that must be resisted, yes–but more, something that must be overcome."

– Dr. Craig Hill, dean of United Methodist-related Perkins School of Theology, Southern Methodist University, on Facebook.

    Over Summer 2017, United Methodist Insight has gained 2,000 more supporters for its mission to see and interpret the church and the world through the lens of Jesus Christ's teachings. We now reach a community of more than 9,000 readers seeking to discern God's will for The United Methodist Church. We hope you'll join us on our journey. Please click on the Donate button above for online giving. Or make checks payable to our sponsoring congregation, St. Stephen UMC, and write "UM Insight" on the memo line. Then mail to United Methodist Insight, c/o St. Stephen United Methodist Church, 2520 Oates Drive, Mesquite, TX 75150. Thank you!


Get United Methodist Insight Weekly!

* indicates required