The Problem with the Golden Calf Story



Comments (6)

Comment Feed

Re-Read Ex. 19-24

I was recently reading through this passage, had some questions of my own, and came upon this thread. As it has been mentioned, the people heard the commandments in chapter 20. In chapter 19, God says He will have a cloud so the people can hear and required them all to consecrate themselves prior to. Even if they didn't hear God's voice, in chapter 24, Moses tells them all the commandments, and the Israelites agree to them as well as some other rules listed in the chapters in between. They agree to enter a covenent with God keeping these rules. Moses writes it down and is then called back up the mountain to receive the actual tablets. I don't know that what Moses did was wrong considering he saved them all. God was ready to wipe them out and start over with Moses. To say that they would be breaking the commandment of killing isn't quite a sound argument, because there were many laws given that will result in death as a means of justice which is what this was.

What you said in the last two paragraphs has been something, I've been thinking on a lot. Who is God? I'm not sure we will ever, like you said, be able to explain Him definitely.

I didn't I know this thread is old but thought I would add this info here for anyone else that might stumble upon it.

Briana Bean 14 days ago

Not true - the people knew

No excuses - they heard the commandments. Moses was not on the mountain in Exodus 20 until the end of the chapter. He was down with the people when God spoke the Ten Commandments. Everyone heard and they were afraid, they told Moses about their fear and that is when Moses went up the mountain.

Lee more than 2 years ago

Out of Egypt and Finding What is Right

The Golden Calf represented both the Good Life (sirloin, rib eye) and the gods worshiped in Egypt. So they know better than to worship it before the Ten Commandments. They had just come from Egypt and it was full of idols of every sort. They knew from Abraham there was only one God and not to worship idols.

We need to be careful not to compare God's righteous judgment with that of terrorists. Those worshiping the pagan idol and those living out immorality of all manner received their just reward from God. We cannot tell God what is just, for He knows. It is we that need to take our sense of justice and morality from God. When we play by God's rules we bring honor to Him and He will reward His faithful servants. God's grace was shown by those who were guilty, but spared when Moses call them to turn from their sin, including his brother Aaron.

Skipper Anding more than 4 years ago

Herein lies...

Herein lies the Gordian Knot of Bilblical interpretation; is God's authority invested in his Word or in my interpretation of it?

Charles Whatley more than 4 years ago

God's righteous judgement

Well said, Skipper Anding. God made man in HIS image. We do not make God in OUR image.

Wanda Scofield more than 3 years ago

Divinity is foolishness

Pagan means "non Christian", and they weren't even Jews then, were they?
We're they Jews, Israelites, Hebrews or Jewish people at this point?

Tyrion 148 days ago

We Appreciate Your Support

     As we face challenging times, United Methodist Insight welcomes your financial support to bring you news and views of The United Methodist Church in a world seeking a new future.

     TEXT your contribution to 84-321 with "(amt) Insight" via your smartphone or go to Your additional contribution of the 2.2% processing fee will make your donation go farther.

     Make CHECKS payable to our sponsoring congregation, St. Stephen UMC, and write "UM Insight" on the memo line. Then mail to United Methodist Insight, c/o St. Stephen United Methodist Church, 2520 Oates Drive, Mesquite, TX 75150. Thank you!